Year  Mustangs of the Year Other Recipients 

 2017 Matthew Burke, Kelsey Perretta Jane Beiermeister, Dominic Fano, Cassie Gologorsky

Jonathan Kraft, Michael Trezza, Tyler Weiss

2016 Nick Khalaf, Jennifer Jasterzbski Max Carus, Brock Caudill, Gina DelloStritto

Madison Hill, Kelly O'Reilly, Harrison Sonn

2015 Jenny Lake, Anthony Fano Jillian Garfunkel, Rachel Inglesino, Jacob Kaplan

Kevin, Koske, Sean Manning, Thomas Marabondo

2014 Carly DeNigris, Katie O'Reilly Tyler Benson, Michael Biase, Jason Calcagno

Kirsten Godau, Kayla Lewis, Joe Salamone